But until then I am content to offer my ramblings in print and I hope that you'll continue to enjoy reading them. And with that having been said I suppose it's time to get to my latest post!
TRUE FAILURE ONLY COMES WHEN WE STOP TRYING
Think back to when you were younger, much younger. Back to the time when you could be anything you ever dreamed. Recall the time in your life when it was all real. You could do magic, you could walk a tightrope or you could be a racecar driver knowing that every trick would be a success, you could fall a thousand feet and still land with a smile on your face, and you could crash over and over again without getting so much as a scratch.
Do you remember how it could have been four degrees below zero outside and you and your friends would have pitched tents and lived on the playground if some relatively sane adult didn’t force you to line up and go back inside so you could have story time? Yes, if that annoying person hadn’t ushered you back into the warmth and security of the indoors, you were fairly certain you and your buddies could have foraged for nuts and berries and you’d have been perfectly fine. Because back then everything was possible.
But if I’m being honest, it wasn’t always lollipops and lemon drops back then for any of us. There were a few things we could have lived without. Like kickball. Ah, yes kickball; the king of playground sports. Remember how we stood in line waiting to be picked; hoping we were worthy of being chosen by the ‘it’ kids whose index fingers had the power to either draw us into their schoolyard fold or to stab us in our ever hopeful souls?
If you were cool you always got picked early. However, if you were like the majority of little kids around the world, you had to sweat it out, praying to whatever deity your parents made you believe in that you’d make it on a team before the final two because you were bright enough back then to realize that the length of time you had to stand in the god-awful ‘pick-me' line showed your position in the proverbial (primary school) pecking order.
No doubt we all, at least once, have felt the painful sting of being chosen last and those are the sorts of memories that stay with a person for a very long time; molding them into the adults they eventually become. But, we’re older now…wiser. And we’ve matured enough to realize how childish it was to dwell on such trivial things.
Oh please! Are you serious? You can rationalize all you want, but it doesn’t negate the fact that being picked last sucks. Go ahead and admit it. It bugged you then and it still bugs you now. And it’s perfectly okay to be a perturbed about your past but you mustn’t let the anger or regrets you may have bottled up during your youth rule the life you now have because we all must acknowledge what was so we can move forward to what is.
After all it’s those times when we stood in line waiting, hoping we’d be picked, and believe me we’ve all stood in a line like the dreaded kickball line at one time or another in our lives, that taught us so much about ourselves and the world. We learned resiliency, composure, and patience. All of which are lessons that we hope our own children will also learn and grow from.
Of course in today’s touchy-feely politically correct world, we’ve been told by ‘experts in the field of educational psychology’ that children shouldn’t be allowed to ‘pick-n-choose’ teammates as it might lead to a negative impact on the psyche of the children who get chosen last. And according to these sage experts if we so much as hint to a child that he or she might not be the absolute best at everything they try, be it sports or academics, we’re setting them up for a lifetime of failure.
They, those experts, also suggest that as we move toward a grand world order there should be a sense of blind equality in our schools that will one day filter out to the mainstream. Because, they say, when we close our eyes, everyone is the same. But the world is far too beautiful to shut our eyes to it and quite frankly it’s those differences that make life worth living. Besides if you walk around with your eyes closed you’re liable to take a sixty story step…straight down.
Maybe that's why those of us who live in the real world have a hard time swallowing those particular pills of wisdom because no matter how heavily sugar coated we make things so that everyone has a chance to feel special, there will always be a first and a last even if it’s an unspoken ranking. But please don’t get me wrong, I do understand and believe whole heartedly that we all need to feel the exhilaration that comes from individual successes as well as team driven accomplishments. And that people, in general, should be encouraged to try all sorts of new things if for no reason other than to broaden one’s horizons.
However I also think it’s important to note that we cannot all be ‘the best’ at everything we try but we certainly can try our best to be all we can be. And to be honest, sometimes we learn more about ourselves through our flaming crashes than we ever learn from our golden victories. So failure isn’t always a bad thing.
But unfortunately failure isn't really an option for children today because the mere notion of failure (regardless of whether it may actually lead to a positive, character building event) is viewed as a cancer in the perfect little world where educational psychologists live and dole out their wisdom to other educators. And because children are never given a chance to fail, they can't make all those mistakes from which some of the most important lessons in life are learned. Chief among them being: True failure only comes when we stop trying.
Good grief, if it wasn’t for common sense logic like that, we’d still be reading by gas lights because it took Thomas Edison, the Wizard of Menlo Park, thousands of attempts before he figured out how to make a filament that could resist an electric current without burning up or outright exploding within the glass bulbs in which he placed them. And when asked about his numerous failures with the design of the light bulb Edison said, “I have not failed. I’ve just figured out 10,000 ways that won’t work.”
Edison's never give up attitude should be an inspiration to children today. But instead of inspiring effort, words like his tend to fall on deaf ears. Because children who don’t know what failure is, just don’t get it and sadly they never will.
And then when they grow up and join the ranks of those of us living in Adult-land and have to deal with all the everyday ups and downs that come with being a grown up they're overwhelmed because they never learned how to pick themselves up and brush the dust of their britches when they get knocked backwards by the hand of Fate. But what do I know? I'm not an educational psychologist. Granted I did teach middle and high school for twelve years and saw first hand how children who'd never failed at anything were crushed sometimes beyond consolation by truly trivial things which they should have learned to take in stride years earlier.
Personally, I’m amazed that I ever made it to adulthood considering how awful my childhood was. Geez, I can’t even begin to count the number of times I played Duck, Duck, Goose and was never picked to run like an idiot around the circle. Yes, I’m sure my social and emotional growth was forever stunted because of it. But thank God the children of today will never have to endure ridicule of that magnitude ever again because Duck, Duck, Goose is one of those dastardly, psychologically scarring games that has been outlawed by forward thinking educational gurus.
And gosh I’m afraid to even consider how much brighter I’d be today if only my teachers had left me alone so that I could discover how in the heck to work with fractions as opposed to being shown how to actually use the proportional things. I’m also positive that I could have one day gotten a job at NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory if only my teachers had just let me be when I was trying to figure out if I really could get the daylights shocked out of me by sticking a pair of scissors into an electrical outlet.
But apparently I didn’t need guidance back when I was growing up. No, all I really needed was to hear someone to say, “Wow, you are so special” and I'd have been absolutely fine.
22 comments:
A good post, Avery, and so true! My wife is a Teaching Assistant in the local Primary school and when she tells me about new 'initiatives'I despair. Competition and failure? What's that? Surprise surprise, it's the real world waiting to shake you by the hand.
Antony
Antony,
I agree whole heartedly! I know all those initiatives even those with the best of intentions always used to drive me batty. But then again, you know what they say about the road to Hell...it's paved with good intentions!
And thank you for giving me a positive nod!
Avery
I'm a retired gymnastics coach, so I know the value of failure. I used to ask the kids after a practice: "How many times did you fail today? A hundred? Tomorrow, make it two hundred!" The message is always: "Don't get discouraged. With practice and patience you'll get there."
This certainly resonates with me, but less as a kid and more as a parent and teacher.
You took the words out of my mouth, and I wrote about this topic in a post a while back. This hand holding culture drives me nuts. Well lots of things drive me nuts, but that's for another time.
If you're interested...on our site....Under Categories: The Guy's Horizon.
"The Future of Being Politically Correct"
Hope you're having a good weekend. Your blog was one of the sites we featured in our new post today. Enjoy!
PS. I used to get picked first in those kickball games, but I never felt part of the IN CROWD!
To Nothingprofound,
What a great comment and what an even greater outlook! So many kids today want instant gratification but they don't realize how much greater the accomplishments are if they really have to work for them. I'll bet you were a great coach!
Thanks so much for taking the time to send me such a nice comment!
Avery
To One of the Guys,
First of all let me say thank you for your kind recognition. And I look forward to popping over to your site to read your post about our crazy PCness!
And I totally understand what you say about how this particular post really touches you now as a parent & a teacher.
As for getting picked first in all those kickball games...I'll forgive you this time! I was one of those 'middle picked kids' so I guess I was only sort of bad at kickball!
I hope your day is going well, too!
Avery
I truly enjoyed this post.
-Anne Marie
I like Edison's attitude, failing should encourage us. Abraham Lincoln failed over and over but ended up the US President.
Enjoyable read.
Mike
To Anne Marie,
I truly thank you and am so glad you enjoyed it!
To Mike,
Thank you so much for the kind words. I agree whole heartedly. It's amazing what we can do if we put our minds to it. Lincoln is such a great example. And so is George Washington...the man lost more battles in the American Revolution than he won...BUT he won the ones that really counted! So you can never say 'ah, who cares...it doesn't count for much' because you never know what 'counts for much' until all is said and done!
Again, thank you both!
Avery
I so love that Edison quote. Attitude in life is everything. We defeat ourselves more often than anyone else can ever defeat us. We stop trying. True words Avery, and an excellent post!
L'Avery ---
Looking forward to podcast rambles. There is something about a Southern accent...
In grad school, I did a paper on Eudora Welty and when I read a long quote from her, to the class, I did it in my Mother-in-law's accent (MIL was from rural South Carolina), on the theory that in order to really appreciate the syntax of the Southern writer, one had to hear its vocal inflections.
It was either one of my most brilliant moments in grad school, or I sounded like an utter buffoon -- pretty sure there was no middle ground.
To Blasier,
I'm sure it was a wonderful presentation! So long as you didn't go for the overkill, that is! :o)
And as I write this little note, I'm taking a break from recording my very first post 'A Little Bit about the South' from back in April of 09...hopefully we'll have that podcast thing up and going soon!
Thanks so much for the comment!
Avery
I would love to hear your podcasts, because I adore accents from the American south!
Great post.
Avery,
I can't tell you how many times I have had a conference with parents about allowing children to take risks and not be afraid to fail. They want to be there every time little Johnny falls and what they don't realize is that they are feeding his insecurity in himself by doing so!
To Sandbox,
Thank you so very kindly. I've always loved simple, no nonsense quotes like those of Lincoln, Edison, and even Einstein... Amazing people they were.
Again thank you!
Avery
To TattyTiara,
I'm working on it. But don't be upset if I don't sound like I stepped off the plantation! I've been told I'm a rather articulate speaker (drat those acting classes) and have an uncanny knack for 'losing' the sound when I want to...but I promise I'll keep it tied around my finger so it can't get lost!
To VKT,
Oh, those dreaded conferences...how I remember them so well. If we could get the parents over their fears the children would be A-OK. We've all got to learn to fall, laugh it off, wipe off our knees and get right back up so we can prove to our children and ourselves that the world will not stop spinning if we stumble here and there.
Thank you all for your great and kind comments!
Avery
I hated dodge ball and I was always chosen last for games. Ironically, I'm now a substitute teacher, and which job do I get called for the most? Yes, to teach gym. I only had three days of work last week - all PE!
To Theresa,
Oh how I loathed dodge ball. But I was SO small in elementary school I could hide behind the big kids until they were all beaned! Then there I was...out in the open. Oh dread!
I do some substitute teaching, too. But I've yet to ever accept a PE post. I was a cheerleading sponser for many years...I've been there-done that!
Thanks for the comment. Have a great day.
Avery
Funny, Hubby and I were discussing this topic this very morning when we somehow began talking about an old co-worker of his. This person came from a successful family and was a Yale graduate, yet somehow he just couldn't function properly in the "real" world. There was just a complete lack of common sense. We were chuckling about the time he went to a meeting at a prestigious NY agency dressed in a hawaiian shirt, shorts and flip-flops. He got escorted out. I mentioned to Hubby this morning that his parents must have done something fundamentally wrong.
It could be worse, but someday we will really have to face the results of all the children who are coddled and protected from failure and hard knocks.
To Rebecca,
Ah, that Real World it can be daunting even for those of us who have a clue imagine what it must be like for those who don't!
Thankfully I think my daughter is fairly well adjusted and being that she's a rather competitive girl she loves the thrill of victory and has learned that instead of seeing 'failures' or 'anything less than 1st' as being stumbling blocks. Rather she sees them as stepping stones. I suppose it's all in how we look at things!
Thank you again for your great comment.
Avery
My dear Avery, You are indeed a good writer and you have the first and perhaps only requirement for being an artist: The love of the thing. Ambition is for those who get no satisfaction from what they do. Recognition is nice but of no lasting value. Changing the world is a noble idealbut perhaps, the world is contrived so that it can't be changed.
Bluntly, all an artist can do is please himself. This is another blunt truth they don't teach in school.
I have lived for 3/4's of a century and have always worked as an artist and always known that this was what I was supposed to be. So, there is another group of people(children, young barbarians, and adults) out there who hope you will join them and ignore the learned"wisdom" of the academics and the fearful ones
cowered by their own cherished ignorance, and continue to write for yourself alone. I picked up a copy of "The Catcher In The Rye" today. I had read it many years ago and I was again struck by the "voice" of the book and how vivid it still is after all these years. I think I understand why Salinger published so little else and withdrew from the literary world.
My best.
To Count Sneaky,
Thank you so very much for your words of support! And I do very much love writing. I suppose that some people might get tired of hearing me rave about it but I suppose it's my 'joyful noise' and I cannot help but make it.
And I absolutely agree with you about Salinger. It is a rare thing to read something and truly hear the words as if the writer had written then expressly for you which is how Catcher caught so many people.
Rare indeed. Again, thank you so very kindly.
Avery
Amazing, and so true. Our schools, and the environment we are brought up in feels more stifling than anything else. We tell kids "You can be anything!", but we don't go on to back that in our actions. And really, I think it's because at a certain point, right around the time we lose out innocence, we learn to be scared. We learn to fear failure and getting hurt.
What could we achieve if we never learned that? How much farther could we get?
To Michael Thomas,
How very true! FDR wasn't joking when he said, 'the only thing we have to fear is fear itself'
Failure is nothing more than a hurdle to overcome! Now I might not be the tallest woman (or for that matter the most coordinated) but I sure as heck can jump...and in my mind I can soar!
I often wonder the same thing of humanity...how much more would we, could we be if only we let ourselves simply be?
Thank you so much for your lovely comment!
Avery
Post a Comment